Quantcast

Miami Pushes “Disparate Impact” Shakedown Suit Against Big Banks

(VDare) The City of Miami is suing Bank of America and Wells Fargo for Fair Housing Act violations, with a Rube Goldberg-causation argument that goes like this:

  • The banks “racistly” lent money to blacks for home mortgages
  • The mortgages weren’t paid and the homes foreclosed
  • Thus depriving Miami of tax revenue
  • Which the banks should now pay to Miami

(See Bank of America v. Miami, by Ilya Shapiro, Trevor Burrus, and Sam Spiegelman, Cato Legal Briefs, December 20, 2019.)

It’s absurd on a few levels, but I never fail to be amused that when banks don’t lend to minorities, it’s “redlining“—and racist.  When they do lend money, it’s “predatory“—and racist.

Racist if you do, racist if you don’t. 

To get their win, Miami’s lawyers are relying on “disparate impact” theory.

Under the theory, private business decisions or local government policies that aren’t motivated by race are tagged unlawful anyway because they have a statistically different impact on members of a given racial group. 

In other words, if blacks simply have worse credit ratings, and as a result are charged higher mortgage rates, that’s “disparate impact”.

[Read more…]

TRENDING NOW

Antifa Threatens to Destroy Portland Bookstore for Carrying Book

(Sovereign Man) A book by Andy Ngo called Unmasked: Inside Antifa’s Radical Plan to Destroy Democracy, is about the violent tactics that...

Biden Proposes Massive $1.9 Trillion in Handouts

(Money Metals Exchange) Metals markets and financial markets have seemingly been unaffected by recent political turmoil. Investors have...

Amazon Pulls All ‘Stop the Steal’ Merchandise

(Headline USA) Amazon pulled all merchandise containing the slogan “Stop the Steal” from its online store, according to Reclaim the Net. Thousands...

2 Nuke Plants, 1 Bribery Scandal, No Answers

(Associated Press) For much of the past four years, the residents of a pair of villages along Lake Erie have been on...

Expecting Trouble, DC Locks Down a Week Before Inauguration

(Associated Press) All through downtown Washington, the primary sound for several blocks was the beeping of forklifts unloading more fencing.